Join Jerry Eicher in an enlightening episode of "Exploring Further," where we delve into the profound theological debates surrounding the concept of new birth in Anabaptist and Reformed theology. This episode seeks to answer the complex question: Is the self totally depraved? Jerry argues in favor of the Anabaptist belief that a true believer experiences a literal new birth in Christ, contrasting sharply with Reformed perspectives that emphasize justification of the original self. We explore insights from C.S. Lewis on the necessity of rebirth and critically analyze Reformed doctrine through the lens of Greek philosophical influences that suggest an uncorrupted soul. The discussion examines R.C. Sproul's rejection of certain Greek views, yet questions the embrace of others regarding the soul's nature. We also trace the historical perspectives of Augustine and Aquinas, and how these have shaped current theological thought. This episode challenges listeners to reconsider the essence of the soul, the impact of sin, and the transformative power of rebirth through the Holy Spirit. Understand why the Anabaptist emphasis on a new self in Christ calls for a significant shift from traditional doctrines, making this a radically relevant dialogue for today's theological reflections.
